Is passive investing in green bonds greenwashing?

by | Sep 2, 2021 | News

monkey image in green forest

Don’t get me wrong, passive investing has a clear role for investors looking for a cost-efficient exposure to financial markets. In the realm of green bonds, it does raise serious questions though.

Taking your typical green bond index, this is a “free-for-all” of corporates having issued green bonds meeting certain standards of “quality” (typically meeting ICMA green bond standards). Investing in a fund tracking the index implies being comfortable buying green bonds from every single issuer. As the index does not screen for the issuers’ ESG credentials, this will include ESG laggards. Even more worrying is financing issuers that issue green bonds purely tactically – because they can. I doubt that there is a single issuer in the EUR IG market that would not be able to find half a billion green assets on its balance sheet and be able to issue a green bond. By indiscriminately financing every single green bond issuer, this is in a way of encouraging those without a genuine sustainability purpose to enter the market. They get a “greenium” benefit of coming in green format, and don’t even have to change their business – hooray. By genuine purpose I do mean where green bonds are a tool to support a clear environmental/climate strategy. For sustainablility-focused investors, common sense would dictate steering clear of issuers that have not made commitments to shift their business. It’s too easy to be satisfied when financing a few green assets regardless of the rest of the balance sheet – not worrying about what is under water when looking at an iceberg.

All investors have different sustainability objectives and convictions, hence a view of ESG leaders and laggards that justifiably differs. Nevertheless, not having a view is alike either encouraging the entrance of “weak” issuers in the green bond market or buying green bonds for marketing purposes, in both cases it smells like greenwashing.

  • The Valuation date: November 25, 2025
    serie AsOFDateFK FundName ISIN MTD MTD YTD YTD SI SI
    1 20,251,125 GAM Sustainable Climate Bond fund IE000BSJBO14 -0.22 -0.0022 0.0346 3.46 0.0191 1.91
    2 20,251,125 GAM Star Crdt Ops EUR Inv IE00B50JD354 -0.23 -0.0023 0.0395 3.95 0.7313 73.13
    3 20,251,125 GAM Star Crdt Ops GBP Inv IE00B510J173 -475.84 0.0001 0.0582 5.82 1.0566 105.66
    4 20,251,125 GAM Star Crdt Ops USD Inv IE00B5769310 0.30 0.0030 0.0702 7.02 0.9821 98.21

  • Please read this important legal information before proceeding.

    Information contained herein are solely for the use of the person who has accessed this information and may not be reproduced or distributed, even partially, to any other person or entity.

    The material contained herein is confidential and intended solely for the use of the persons or entities with nationality of or respectively with their residence, domicile, registered office or effective administration in a State or Country in which distribution, publication, making available or use of the information is not contrary to applicable laws or any other regulation.

    The material contained herein is aimed at sophisticated, professional, eligible, institutional and/or qualified investors/intermediaries who have the knowledge and financial sophistication to understand and bear the risks associated with the investments described.

    The information is solely product-related and does not take into account any personal circumstances and does not qualify as general or personal investment recommendation or advice. In particular, the information is given by way of information only and does not constitute a specific legal offer for the purchase or sale of financial instruments. Moreover, nothing contained herein is constitutive of any tax advice.

    Every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the financial information herein but the information contained herein has not been independently reviewed or verified. Therefore, Atlanticomnium SA gives no assurance, express or implied, as to whether such information is accurate, true or complete and no responsibility is accepted by Atlanticomnium SA for any errors or omissions. Third-party content is the property of its respective provider or its licensor and is protected by applicable copyright law.

    Past performance is not indicative of future performance. The price of shares/units and the income from the funds/trusts can go down as well as up and may be affected by changes in rates of exchange or financial markets fluctuation, out of the scope of Atlanticomnium SA.

    To the fullest extent permitted by law, in no event shall Atlanticomnium SA or our affiliates, or any of our directors, employees, contractors, service providers or agents have any liability whatsoever to any person for any direct or indirect loss, liability, cost, claim, expense or damage of any kind, whether in contract or in tort, including negligence, or otherwise, arising out of or related to the use of the information provided.

    • AgreeCancel
    PERFORMANCE